WHAT DO WE DO NOW? INVESTIGATING, EVALUATING AND DEFENDING THE TRUCKING ACCIDENT CLAIM - 2009 UPDATE

Sep 30, 2026

Texas Insurance and Tort Law Update addresses how to investigate, evaluate, and defend commercial trucking accident claims, emphasizing that trucking litigation differs materially from passenger-car cases. It frames the matter through federal regulatory requirements affecting driver status and conduct, outlines evidence preservation and early response steps, and connects these to trial-focused litigation theories. The document then discusses evaluation and damages, including comparative fault, negligence theories, expert testimony, and Texas jurisdictional considerations such as venue rules and jurisdictional hot spots.

LanguageEnglish

CategoryResearch & Report

FormatPDF

Pages34

Reading Time1 h 26 min

AccessFree to download

I. INTRODUCTION

A. Not Just a Car Accident

B. Key Federal Regulations

C. Driver Qualification File

II. PRESERVATION OF EVIDENCE AND EARLY RESPONSE

A. Driver Interviews

B. Eyewitness Statements

C. Law Enforcement Accident Scene Investigations

III. LITIGATION

A. Negligence of the Driver / Respondeat Superior

B. Negligence Per Se

C. Direct Negligence by the Carrier

IV. EVALUATION

A. Proportionate Responsibility and Comparative Fault in Texas

B. Damages

V. TEXAS JURISDICTIONAL ANALYSIS

A. Venue Rules

B. Jurisdictional “Hot Spots”

TEXAS INSURANCE AND TORT LAW UPDATE 2009 SHERATON-HOUSTON-BROOKHOLLOW SEPTEMBER 10, 2009 WHAT DO WE DO NOW? INVESTIGATING, EVALUATING AND DEFENDING THE TRUCKING ACCIDENT CLAIM BRANDON E. BERG Thompson Coe Cousins & Irons One Riverway, Suite 1600 Houston, Texas 77056 (713) 403-8210 WHAT DO WE DO NOW? INVESTIGATING, EVALUATING AND DEFENDING THE TRUCKING ACCIDENT CLAIM I. INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................................... 1 A. Not Just a Car Accident ............................................................................ 1 B. Key Federal Regulations ........................................................................... 1 1. Hours of Service Rules..................................................................2 2. Driver Qualifications .....................................................................2 3. Driver Disqualifications ................................................................3 a) Disqualification for Loss of Driving Privileges ..................3 b) Disqualification for Criminal and Other Offenses ..............3 c) Disqualifying Offenses ......................................................3 4. Application for Employment Requirements...................................4 5. Physical Qualification of Drivers...................................................5 6. Investigation and Inquiries ............................................................6 7. Driver Qualification File ...............................................................6 8. Post-Accident Testing ...................................................................7 a) Alcohol..............................................................................7 b) Controlled Substance Testing ............................................7 9. Random Intoxicant Testing ...........................................................7 10. Reasonable Suspicion Intoxicant Testing.......................................8 II. PRESERVATION OF EVIDENCE AND EARLY RESPONSE .............................................8 A. Driver Interviews ......................................................................................9 B. Eyewitness Statements..............................................................................9 C. Law Enforcement Accident Scene Investigations .................................... 10 D. The Accident Scene ................................................................................ 11 E. The Accident Vehicles ............................................................................ 12 F. On-Board Electronics ............................................................................. 12 1. Event Data Recorders.................................................................. 13 2. Wireless Satellite Communications ............................................. 14 III. LITIGATION......................................................................................................... 14 A. Negligence of the Driver / Respondeat Superior...................................... 14 B. Negligence Per Se................................................................................... 14 C. Direct Negligence by the Carrier............................................................. 15 1. Negligent Entrustment................................................................. 15 2. Negligent Retention, Hiring, and Supervision.............................. 16 D. Expert Testimony ................................................................................... 16 1. Accident Reconstruction ............................................................. 16 2. Event Data Recorder Downloads................................................. 17 3. Federal Regulations Expert ......................................................... 18 4. Biomechanics / Occupant Kinematics ..............

FAQs

Why is a trucking accident lawsuit different from a passenger car collision case?

Trucking cases involve distinct regulatory and operational realities, including the scale and weight of commercial vehicles and the associated standards governing driver qualification and conduct.

What federal regulations are highlighted for driver qualification and related investigations?

The document points to rules such as Hours of Service and driver qualification requirements, including grounds for disqualification and related application requirements.

What are the key litigation and evaluation topics for defending a trucking accident claim in Texas?

It covers preservation of evidence and early response, negligence-based theories, expert testimony (e.g., accident reconstruction and event data recorders), evaluation of comparative fault, damages, and Texas jurisdictional issues like venue rules.

Sep 30, 2026

Upload by Quinn Holloway