The Middle School Concept Meets the Age of Assessments - How One Middle School Has Adapted to the New Age

Oct 15, 2026

Upload by jayni

The study examines how the middle school concept, grounded in effective instruction for pre-adolescent learners, responds to the heightened demands of high-stakes testing following NCLB. A qualitative follow-up to a Tennessee statewide quantitative survey was conducted by visiting the school with the strongest interest and implementation of the concept. Despite increasing accountability and standardization pressures, the principal and staff believe the middle school model best supports young adolescents’ educational needs, while requiring coordinated planning and governance.

LanguageEnglish

CategoryExam

FormatPDF

Pages6

Reading Time15 min

AccessFree to download

Introduction

The Visit

CIMLE Current Issues in Middle Level Education (2011) 16(2), 7-12 The Middle School Concept Meets the Age of Assessments: How One Middle School Has Adapted totheNewAge Allen H. Seed, Ph.D. The University of Memphis Cherry Watts, Ph. D. The University of Tennessee at Martin The Middle School Concept brings together good teaching practices with the unique needs of pre-adolescent students. Since the passing of the NCLB, more and more attention has been generated on the results of high stakes testing. The question of what happens to the middleschool concept when it confronts the demandsof this newage of testing is critical in understanding howto meet the multiple needs of the students and the school’s need for accountability. This qualitative study follows a previous quantitative study conducted to determinethe state of the middle school concept in Tennessee. The school with the highest interest in and implementation of the middle school concept was visited by the authors. They found that despite the pressure from escalating accountability and standardization efforts by the state and federal governments, the principal and staff at this school still believe that the middle school concept best meets the educational needs of young adolescents. Introduction The middle school concept brings together good teaching practices with the unique needs of pre-adolescent students. Since the passing of the NCLB, more and more attention has been generated on the results of high stakes testing. The question of what happens to the middle school concept when it confronts the demandsof this new age of testing is critical in understanding how to meet the multiple needs of the students and the school’s need for accountability. A little over a year ago, The Tennessee Professors of Middle Level Education (TPOMLE) conducted a statewide survey of middle schools. The first target of the survey was to determine the degree to which the principles of the middle school concept are considered important to middle level educators. The second area of interest was the degree to which those concepts were implemented atthe respondents’school settings. Based on the work of George and Alexander in The Exemplary Middle School (2003), the middle school concept was defined in this study by 17 themes. See Table A for a side-by-side comparison of these themes to the characteristics laid out in the recent position statement This We Believe: Keys to Educating Young Adolescents (2010). The survey had three components: curricular characteristics, instructional and advisory issues, and governance. Responses to the questionnaire came from 684 educators, both administrators and teachers from 64 school systems across Tennessee. Although not all systems participated in the survey, the responses were widely distributed across the state. Initial findings from the survey found that respondents generally found the principles of the middle school concept of great to greatest importance. In general, the majority of respondents felt that their school implemented middle school concepts at least moderately well. When we examined rankings from the schools that yielded the highest means for importance and implementation of the middle school concept themes, one school stood out. It was this school that was targeted to visit. The Visit This rural West Tennessee middle school sits in the middle of rolling fields of soybeans and cotton. There are 575 students—the majority Caucasian, with a stable population of about 80 African-American students and 80 Hispanic students. The Hispanic students are not from the families of migrant workers, but have permanent homes in the community. The special education program uses the inclusion model, with the exception of a small developmental classroom for students with severe disabilities. “If it benefits the students, we’ll do it” stated the principal of this rural county middle school. The principal is a former highschool assista

FAQs

What is the core purpose of the study described in the text?

To understand what happens to the middle school concept when it confronts the demands of the new age of high-stakes testing, and how schools can meet students’ multiple needs while maintaining accountability.

How was the qualitative study conducted in Tennessee?

It followed a prior statewide quantitative survey that assessed importance and implementation of the middle school concept; the school with the highest interest and implementation was then visited by the authors.

What did the authors find about the school’s response to accountability and standardization pressures?

Despite pressure from escalating accountability and standardization, the principal and staff still believe the middle school concept best meets the educational needs of young adolescents.

Oct 15, 2026

Upload by jayni