Composition Forum 41 - Extending the “Warming Trend” to Writing - Transfer Research: Investigating Transformative Experiences with Writing Concepts

Oct 15, 2026

Uploaded by kopisore

The article investigates Transformative Experience (TE) as a new construct for conceptualizing learning transfer grounded in writing knowledge. Drawing on educational psychology research, the study uses a brief qualitative case study of faculty members writing for scholarly publication and survey responses from a formal writing group. It illustrates TE’s three dimensions—active use, expansion of perception, and experiential value—and argues TE can widen the “warming trend” in transfer research while informing writing pedagogy through proposed instructional interventions.

LanguageEnglish

CategoryResearch & Report

FormatPDF

Pages16

Reading Time40 min

AccessFree to download

Composition Forum 41, Spring 2019

Extending the “Warming Trend” to Writing - Transfer Research

Transformative Experience (TE) as a Framework for Transfer

Current Issue From the Editors Weblog Editorial Board Editorial Policy Submissions Archives Accessibility Search Composition Forum 41, Spring 2019 Extending the “Warming Trend” to Writing Transfer Research: Investigating Transformative Experiences with Writing Concepts Sandra L. Tarabochia and Benjamin C. Heddy Abstract: In this article, we investigate a new construct for conceptualizing learning transfer with writing knowledge: Transformative Experience (TE) . With origins in educational psychology, TE has been effective for promoting transfer with scientific concepts in previous research, but not yet considered in relation to writing or other presumably procedural subjects. To investigate the usefulness of TE for revealing new dimensions of writer development, we present a brief case study focused on faculty members writing for scholarly publication. We use qualitative responses to a survey about faculty members’ experiences in a formal writing group to illustrate the three dimensions of TE in the context of writer development: active use, expansion of perception, and experiential value. Although we study advanced faculty writers, findings have implications for teaching and learning writing more broadly. Specifically, we argue that using TE as a framework for interpreting what learners do with writing knowledge widens the “warming trend” in transfer research, nuancing our understanding of writing transfer by attending to perceptual and experiential aspects of learning. We propose instructional interventions to test how incorporating TE into writing pedagogy might enhance teaching and learning for transfer. The issue of knowledge transfer is a vital concern for writing teachers and writing studies scholars, and a growing body of research addresses teaching and learning writing for transfer (Beaufort; Wardle,“Understanding;” Yancey et al. ; Eodice et al. ; Wardle, Writing and Transfer; Driscoll and Powell; Driscoll and Wells) . Nevertheless, given the unique complexity of writing knowledge and the “ill-structured” contexts that call for its application (integration, adaptation, repurposing, etc. ), determining how writers learn and transfer their learning remains difficult to do (Snead; Wardle,“What Is Transfer?” 144) . In this article, we address this challenge by reporting results from an interdisciplinary collaboration among the authors—a researcher from educational psychology and a researcher from writing studies. More specifically, we explore the potential of TE, a construct from educational psychology, to shed new light on the processes through which learners develop and transfer writing-related knowledge. We argue that TE reveals meaningful aspects of learning that can be obscured by traditional notions of writing transfer that privilege dramatic transformation and don’t always integrate cognitive, behavioral and affective dimensions of learning. As amore integrative framework, TE may bring to light how small, straightforward acts of transfer accumulate and eventually pave the way for more dramatic transfer events. TE usefully complicates theories of transfer that underscore dramatic transformation in how learners see subject matter, themselves and the world. This type of transformation is central to threshold theory, which has significantly informed conceptualizations of writing transfer (Adler-Kassner et al. ; Moore,“Five Essential Principles;” Moore,“Mapping the Questions;” Moore and Anson) . Adler-Kassner and Wardle spearheaded the move to identify and operationalize writing studies threshold concepts—foundational knowledge about writing that is transformative, integrative, and irreversible (Naming What We Know; “Naming What We Know: The Project of this Book” 2) . Threshold concepts have become an important “framework for designing for and understanding transfer of writing knowledge across contexts”(Adler-Kassner et al. ; Moore and Anson 6) . Notably, threshold theory is associated with transforma

FAQs

What is Transformative Experience (TE) in this article?

TE is presented as a construct for conceptualizing learning transfer with writing knowledge. It builds on educational psychology work and focuses on how learners’ perceptions and experiential value develop through writing-related concepts.

How does the study investigate TE for writer development?

The study reports a brief case study centered on faculty members writing for scholarly publication. It uses qualitative responses to a survey about experiences in a formal writing group to illustrate TE’s three dimensions.

What implications does TE have for writing instruction and learning transfer?

The article argues that using TE as a framework can widen the warming trend in transfer research. It proposes instructional interventions to test whether incorporating TE into writing pedagogy enhances teaching and learning for transfer.

Oct 15, 2026

Uploaded by kopisore