[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":-1},["ShallowReactive",2],{"detail-sidebar-cat-0-en-105":3,"doc-seo-532823-105":59,"doc-detail-532823-en":130},{"code":4,"msg":5,"data":6},0,"success",[7,13,18,23,28,33,38,43,48,51,55],{"id":8,"doc_module":4,"doc_module_name":9,"category_name":10,"show_sort_weight":11,"slug":12},1,"Document","Story & Novel",90,"story-novel",{"id":14,"doc_module":4,"doc_module_name":9,"category_name":15,"show_sort_weight":16,"slug":17},2,"Literature",80,"literature",{"id":19,"doc_module":4,"doc_module_name":9,"category_name":20,"show_sort_weight":21,"slug":22},4,"Exam",70,"exam",{"id":24,"doc_module":4,"doc_module_name":9,"category_name":25,"show_sort_weight":26,"slug":27},5,"Comic",60,"comic",{"id":29,"doc_module":4,"doc_module_name":9,"category_name":30,"show_sort_weight":31,"slug":32},6,"Technology",50,"technology",{"id":34,"doc_module":4,"doc_module_name":9,"category_name":35,"show_sort_weight":36,"slug":37},7,"Healthcare",40,"healthcare",{"id":39,"doc_module":4,"doc_module_name":9,"category_name":40,"show_sort_weight":41,"slug":42},8,"Research & Report",30,"research-report",{"id":44,"doc_module":4,"doc_module_name":9,"category_name":45,"show_sort_weight":46,"slug":47},9,"Religion & Spirituality",20,"religion-spirituality",{"id":46,"doc_module":4,"doc_module_name":9,"category_name":49,"show_sort_weight":46,"slug":50},"World Cup","world-cup",{"id":52,"doc_module":4,"doc_module_name":9,"category_name":53,"show_sort_weight":52,"slug":54},10,"Lifestyle","lifestyle",{"id":56,"doc_module":4,"doc_module_name":9,"category_name":57,"show_sort_weight":24,"slug":58},19,"General","general",{"code":4,"msg":60,"data":61},"ok",{"site_id":62,"language":63,"slug":64,"title":65,"keywords":66,"description":67,"schema_data":68,"social_meta":123,"head_meta":125,"extra_data":127,"updated_unix":129},105,"en","forum-contributions-cjeu-case-law-on-exercising-rights-under-eu-llm","Forum_Contributions_CJEU_Case_Law_on_Exercising_Rights_Under_EU - (LLM)","","Examines CJEU VAT case law on exercising rights subject to conditions, focusing on how courts distinguish “substantive” (material) requirements from “formal” ones. It explains that substantive conditions are indispensable prerequisites for VAT exemptions or deductions, while formal requirements mainly support administration and may be disregarded when the substantive criteria are otherwise established. The article tests whether any general framework can be derived from jurisprudence and highlights key invoice-related controversies, including Teleos, Zipvit, Kemwater, and reactions in other jurisdictions.",{"@graph":69,"@context":122},[70,84,105],{"@type":71,"itemListElement":72},"BreadcrumbList",[73,77,79,82],{"item":74,"name":75,"@type":76,"position":8},"https://docshare.wps.com","Home","ListItem",{"item":78,"name":9,"@type":76,"position":14},"https://docshare.wps.com/document/",{"item":80,"name":40,"@type":76,"position":81},"https://docshare.wps.com/document/research-report/",3,{"item":83,"name":65,"@type":76,"position":19},"https://docshare.wps.com/document/forum-contributions-cjeu-case-law-on-exercising-rights-under-eu-llm/532823/",{"url":83,"name":65,"@type":85,"image":86,"author":91,"headline":65,"publisher":94,"fileFormat":97,"inLanguage":63,"description":67,"dateModified":98,"datePublished":99,"encodingFormat":97,"isAccessibleForFree":100,"interactionStatistic":101},"DigitalDocument",{"url":87,"@type":88,"width":89,"height":90},"https://docshare.wps.com/thumbnails/forum-contributions-cjeu-case-law-on-exercising-rights-under-eu-llm/532823.png","ImageObject",300,407,{"name":92,"@type":93},"Taylor Morgan","Person",{"url":74,"name":95,"@type":96},"DocShare","Organization","application/pdf","2026-11-16","2026-10-09",true,{"@type":102,"interactionType":103,"userInteractionCount":29},"InteractionCounter",{"@type":104},"ViewAction",{"@type":106,"mainEntity":107},"FAQPage",[108,114,118],{"name":109,"@type":110,"acceptedAnswer":111},"Why can a formal condition in EU VAT law be non-fatal even when it is not fulfilled?","Question",{"text":112,"@type":113},"Formal conditions are described as administrative tools that facilitate proof of substantive criteria. If the facts can be established otherwise to the satisfaction of tax authorities or a court, the right may still be exercised.","Answer",{"name":115,"@type":110,"acceptedAnswer":116},"What is the key problem the article aims to address regarding the substantive/formal distinction?",{"text":117,"@type":113},"It investigates whether jurisprudence or legislation provides a general test to classify requirements as substantive or formal, enabling legal certainty for taxpayers and authorities.",{"name":119,"@type":110,"acceptedAnswer":120},"How does Kemwater treat invoice-related requirements compared with the Zipvit view?",{"text":121,"@type":113},"In Zipvit, AG Kokott argued that certain invoice information is substantive for VAT deduction. The CJEU in Kemwater rejected any suggestion that the invoice is substantive and treated the document, in its entirety, as a mere formal condition.","https://schema.org",{"og:url":83,"og:type":124,"og:title":65,"og:site_name":95,"og:description":67},"article",{"robots":126,"canonical":83},"index,follow",{"doc_id":128,"site_id":62},532823,1792252249,{"code":4,"msg":5,"data":131},{"doc_id":128,"user_id":132,"nickname":92,"user_avatar":133,"doc_module":4,"category_id":39,"category_name":40,"doc_title":65,"doc_description":67,"doc_content":134,"file_id":135,"file_url":136,"file_type":137,"file_size":138,"view_count":29,"is_deleted":4,"is_public":8,"is_downloadable":8,"audit_status":8,"page_count":39,"language":139,"language_code":63,"site_id":62,"html_lang":63,"table_of_contents":140,"faqs":141,"seo_title":142,"seo_description":67,"update_tm":143,"read_time":46,"preview_page_count":19,"preview_urls":144},1099523885336,"https://ap-avatar.wpscdn.com/davatar_276721f389ce27ea32af1340a28f341c","CJEU Case Law on Exercising Rights under EU VAT:  \nIs There a Golden Thread in the Distinction between Substantive and Formal Conditions?  \nFabian Barth (LLM)  \nElectronic copy available at: [https://ssrn.com/abstract=4471150](https://ssrn.com/abstract=4471150)  \nA. Background  \nWhere legislation explicitly makes a legal right contingent upon the fulfilment of certain conditions, one might prima facie expect that non-compliance with (at least) one of the conditions would be fatal for exercising that right. In EU VAT law however, the issue is more complex.  \nIt emerges from a long line of CJEU case law that, for VAT purposes, provisos are divided into two groups: On the one hand, there are “substantive” or “material”requirements which constitute absolute prerequisites for taxpayers availing themselves of any right granted in VAT law. One example in that regard is the physical movement of goods to another member state, which constitutes an unavoidable necessity in order to treat a supply as a VAT exempt intra-Community supply.1 Formal conditions, by contrast, seem to be “second class provisos” at best. Their mere purpose is to facilitate the administration of VAT by allowing a taxpayer to discharge the burden of evidence for the fulfilment of the substantive criteria. If that practical hurdle of fact-finding can be surmounted otherwise, in a way that convinces the tax authorities or a court, thenon-fulfilment of a formal condition does not prevent a right from being exercised.2 In the light of the foregoing considerations, it cannot be denied that the distinction between “substantive” and “formal” appears to be one of the pillars of EU VAT. It therefore becomes a crucial question how one can assign a requirement to the former or the latter group.  \nThe aim of this article is to investigate whether any general test tackling this issue can be identified. If such a test emerged from the jurisprudence or the legislation, it would facilitate legal certainty since it might allow taxpayers and authorities to anticipate the likely outcome of future CJEU case law in this area.  \n1 CJEU, 27 September 2007, C-409/04 , Teleos plc and others v Commissioners of Customs & Excise, para 42.  \n2 CJEU, 9 December 2021 , C-154/20 , Kemwater ProChemie s. r. o. v Odvolací finanční ředitelství, para 30.  \n-2-  \nElectronic copy available at: [https://ssrn.com/abstract=4471150](https://ssrn.com/abstract=4471150)  \nB. What Makes a Condition “Substantive” or “Formal”?  \na. No Explicit Rule in the Legislation or Case Law  \nAs a starting point, it is worth noting that a distinction between “substantive” and“formal” as such is not envisaged in the EU VAT Directive3 or any secondary legislation. Rather, it seems to be a concept created by the judiciary. Remarkably however, the CJEU has always restricted itself to labelling conditions as “substantive”or “formal” to the extent that it was necessary to answer the questions before it. While helpful guidance and further analyses can be found in academic publications,4 the Court itself refrained however from explicitly outlining any general rule in that regard. The resulting vacuum has let to confusion even amongst experts and done no service to legal certainty.  \nThe status of invoices is only the most glaring example insofar: In her opinion in the Zipvit case, AG Kokott explained at length why she considered at least certain information on an invoice, and hence also the document as a whole, to be substantive conditions for exercising the right to input VAT deduction.5 This view had previously also been expressed by the German Federal Fiscal Court6 and has been echoed in the literature.7 Only five months after the publication of the AG’s opinion, in a different case, Kemwater, the CJEU clearly and unambiguously rejected any suggestion that the invoice would be substantive and degraded the document, in its entirety, to a mere formal condition.8 When this judgment was used as a persuasive source of law in the UK Cou","cbCaieuDj3k4EZkL","https://ap.wps.com/l/cbCaieuDj3k4EZkL","pdf",111842,"English","# Background\n## Substantive and formal requirements in EU VAT\n# What Makes a Condition “Substantive” or “Formal”?\n## No explicit rule in legislation or case law\n## Status of invoices: Zipvit vs Kemwater\n## Brief overview of relevant CJEU case law","[{\"question\":\"Why can a formal condition in EU VAT law be non-fatal even when it is not fulfilled?\",\"answer\":\"Formal conditions are described as administrative tools that facilitate proof of substantive criteria. If the facts can be established otherwise to the satisfaction of tax authorities or a court, the right may still be exercised.\"},{\"question\":\"What is the key problem the article aims to address regarding the substantive/formal distinction?\",\"answer\":\"It investigates whether jurisprudence or legislation provides a general test to classify requirements as substantive or formal, enabling legal certainty for taxpayers and authorities.\"},{\"question\":\"How does Kemwater treat invoice-related requirements compared with the Zipvit view?\",\"answer\":\"In Zipvit, AG Kokott argued that certain invoice information is substantive for VAT deduction. The CJEU in Kemwater rejected any suggestion that the invoice is substantive and treated the document, in its entirety, as a mere formal condition.\"}]","Forum_Contributions_CJEU_Case_Law_on_Exercising_Rights_Under_EU - (LLM) | PDF",1791585263,[145,149,153,157],{"page_no":8,"url":146,"width":147,"height":148},"https://res-academy.cache.wpscdn.com/upload/kdocshare/2026-11-17/0db2a5ccf47216f1920cd71e648bff0b.webp",983,1390,{"page_no":14,"url":150,"width":151,"height":152},"https://res-academy.cache.wpscdn.com/upload/kdocshare/2026-11-17/f50d8cfca8d0c756d0a866225a3dd3a2.webp",982,1388,{"page_no":81,"url":154,"width":155,"height":156},"https://res-academy.cache.wpscdn.com/upload/kdocshare/2026-11-17/29d1e7a7435816cf6be975b642fdbd69.webp",981,1387,{"page_no":19,"url":158,"width":159,"height":160},"https://res-academy.cache.wpscdn.com/upload/kdocshare/2026-11-17/669032a2049061f586b848042afadcd0.webp",980,1385]